Alyssa Valerio
En 102
I chose to write about how important it is to understand people, and to let them be themselves. In each of these stories there is at least one character that is unusual or in unusual circumstances. In "Cathedral" by Raymond Carter a mans wife has an old friend that is coming for a visit, but the husband feels uncomfortable because they're visitor is blind, so he doesn't really want him around. I feel like he should've taken a much more open minded approach, because it meant a lot to his wife and she was getting upset with him the whole night for his behavior. But in the end after having to alone with the blind man he finally sees things his way. The blind man had a wife that he met when he was already blind, that he ended up marrying. The husband how ever could not wrap his mind around how a man can meet a woman, marry her, make love to her and never actually lay eyes on her, his thinking was shallow. After sitting with this blind man, and smoking a little bit of weed his way of thinking evolves. Then, going into "A Painful Case" you read about to characters that are unusual. A man, that is very much to himself. He follows the same ordinary routine most days, only sees family when he must and tells a story about himself in his head. He meets a woman, that sparks his interest and he begins seeing her, and spending a lot of time together. They begin to develop deep feelings for each other, but unfortunately the woman is married. The man decides he wants to go and meet the husband which I found extremely strange, but he didn't want to be sneaky. The woman's husband so negligent of his wife doesn't even suspect anyone could be romantically interested in his wife, so they continue to see each other in her home and quite often find themselves alone. I feel like at this point if they cared for each other this much they should have found a way to be together with out having to hide it because they make each other happy and bring highlight each others best aspects. Shame it was to find out that the man decides to call off their secret relationship so she won't be living a lie and they go there separate ways, which to me sounds vaguely familiar considering every romantic novel thats come out lately, but this ending wasn't very sweet at all. Four years pass by, the man had successfully avoided the woman and reverted to his lonely life. One day over breakfast, he comes across a news paper article, documenting the death of the woman he had held so dear. The article discusses how troubling her last 2 years of life were, as she had picked up a habit of going out and drinking every night and coming home late, she was drowning away her sorrow and misery. Only then did the man realize what he had done, he had given himself to this woman and become someone to value her, appreciate her, listen to her and make her feel strong and loved. He realized his fault, and what he had taken from her when he left. She was left without someone to understand her, and lost her footing. Had he stuck around and saw things through, perhaps things would have ended differently for her. I feel if she had that support and understanding she wouldn't have felt so alone, and not have walked the path that ultimately lead to her death.
Welcome to the blog for Professor Corona's Spring 2015 English 102 class. This blog is meant as an informal site for continuing the discussions that take place in the classroom and for responding to the readings outside it. Please submit your post every week by 6PM on Friday and make sure you read everyone else's posts as well!
Friday, February 6, 2015
Response #1
“Love between man and man is impossible because there must
not be sexual intercourse and friendship between man and women is impossible
because there must be sexual intercourse”.
MR. Duffy loneliness was part of what made him a cold
hearted and isolated person. His attempt to get to meet Mrs. Sinico was a clear
sign that he liked her. They seem to have a connectivity because practically they
were both lonely. Mr. Duffy isolated himself from society’s problems, while
Mrs. Sinico was left alone by her husband because he was always away and her
daughter out giving music lessons. So as timed passed in the story and the more
they got to be with each other and enjoy each other’s company, the more they
were falling in love with each other, which is perfectly normal for two people
who live a lonely live to find a companion, friend and a lover in each other. But
all indicates that Mr. Duffy’s conscience didn't let him continue with their
relationship. Mostly because he might have had a sense of guiltiness because he
knew that Mrs. Sinico had a family and also because it seems that all he ever
wanted was a friend, but intercourse had completely changed the concept.
In cathedral there are a series of
events that address love and friendship, Carver chose to write in dialog and narrating
format to making the story more interesting as you read it. At the beginning of
the story I thought that Robert would end up having an affair with Bub’s wife because
of the way Bub describes Robert at the beginning of the story. It all indicates
that Robert and the wife were very intimate friends and they seemed to have no
secrets whatsoever. Bub seemed little jealous every time his wife talked about
Robert and even more now that he’s going to be sleeping in their house. As the
story progresses I started to think that Bub wasn't uncomfortable with Robert
sleeping in his house, but with the idea that Robert was blind and that he didn't
understand Robert’s way of seeing the world. After they met Robert and Bub
spent the night together getting to know each other and eventually forming a
friendship. Bub understood what it was like to be blind at the end of the story
when Robert asked Bub to draw with him the cathedral they've seen on TV, with
his eye closed.
The third story talks about Mrs. Mallard
who receives the news that her husband had dies in an accident, she locked
herself in the room thinking to herself what her life would be without her
husband now that he is gone. At first I thought she would've been devastated,
but as the story progresses I can see that she was waiting for a moment like
this to happen because with her husband alive she wasn't free. And she had to
be slaved to him for the rest of her life, even though he was her husband she
did not love him anymore and the author mentions that she did not love him most
of the time. Mallard had her sister and Richards worried about her health, but
they didn't know she was feeling a joy inside her now that her husband is dead.
Unluckily for her, her husband shows up at the door and she suffers from heart disease
due to joy that kills.
These three stories have a lot in
common, they all describe relationships between humans. Not necessarily love
relationships but friendships as well, and these relationships happened when
they least expected.
Reading Response #1
Marlena Szumowski
En-102
Reading response #1)
These
three short stories all describe the relationships of a man and a woman. It’s
not necessary a physical relationship but also a friendship that may have
formed within. The authors of these short stories all have a message about the romantic
kind of relationship, and a friendship.
In the short story “Dubliners” by James Joyce, he write about a young man that met a woman. They have eventually became intimate with each other but after a little while they have seemed to break of the intimacy and remained friends, that didn’t last long. James says “Love between man and man is impossible because there must be not sexual intercourse and friendship between man and woman is impossible because there must be sexual intercourse.” This line from the short story basically sums up James view point on friendship. What is means is that to be in love with someone that would be impossible without being sexually involved with the other person. Same as the friendship, he doesn’t see the point of a friendship because to him that too also involves being sexually involved.
Not
everything has to be sexually related and this can be seen in the short story “Cathedral”
by Carver Raymond. “Bub” and his wife are expecting the company of Robert who
was an elderly man whose wife just passed away. Bubs wife used to work and help
the elderly man around 10 years ago. Bub didn’t seem too happy about having
Robert over. He also seemed kind of annoyed because his wife talks quite often
with him and also still remains in touch with the old man. Later that night
after Bubs wife had fallen asleep, Bub and Robert looked as if they had really
connected. The two men started to have a conversation about religion and Robert
was curious as to what a Cathedral looks like. The two men sat on the floor
with Bub drawing and Roberts hand on his following along. I think this was a
great short story of both, physical relationship and a friendship. The physical
relationship played a role in this because it was necessary for Robert to have his
hand on Bubs hand as he was drawing to really try and understand what a
Cathedral may possibly look like. Bubs wife was a link between their friendships,
I feel that Bub saw how much Robert had an effect on his wife and then he too
started to get an understanding of this blind man and a liking to him.
The story of an hour
Reading response # 1
Alicia Stoute
“The story of an hour” really resonated with me because the situation or story line is so similar to situations I have been privy to witness first hand. Mrs. Mallard was in a marriage that she felt trapped in and too often I see both younger and older women getting married to men that are so dominant that the woman eventually loses herself in the marriage. She becomes but another piece of furniture.
Mrs. Mallard had just received news that her husband had died, after the initial tears that were to be expected, she felt a sense of joy and freedom; finally a chance to live for herself, to be her own person, without the domineering presence of her husband.
This story reminded me of stories my mother would telme about the olden days, when women stayed with their husbands weather they loved them or not. In those days it was truly until death do us part; no one was asking for a divorce least of all the woman. These days’ people get married and just as quickly fall out of love with each other. Too many people get married for all the wrong reasons then they find themselves in a less than ideal situation, some kill their spouses to be free of them, many end up in divorce court, and then there are those like Mrs. Mallard who stay in an unhappy marriage.
Mrs. Mallard was already looking forward to a brighter future when she was confronted with the sad truth that her husband was not really dead. The shock was too much for her to bear and she died of a heart attack. I can only hope that women in a similar situation would find a way out of such a marriage. It is my belief that if we all truly took the time to get to know people before jumping into marriage we would have far less divorces, and even less unhappy marriages.
Reading response # 1
Alicia Stoute
“The story of an hour” really resonated with me because the situation or story line is so similar to situations I have been privy to witness first hand. Mrs. Mallard was in a marriage that she felt trapped in and too often I see both younger and older women getting married to men that are so dominant that the woman eventually loses herself in the marriage. She becomes but another piece of furniture.
Mrs. Mallard had just received news that her husband had died, after the initial tears that were to be expected, she felt a sense of joy and freedom; finally a chance to live for herself, to be her own person, without the domineering presence of her husband.
This story reminded me of stories my mother would telme about the olden days, when women stayed with their husbands weather they loved them or not. In those days it was truly until death do us part; no one was asking for a divorce least of all the woman. These days’ people get married and just as quickly fall out of love with each other. Too many people get married for all the wrong reasons then they find themselves in a less than ideal situation, some kill their spouses to be free of them, many end up in divorce court, and then there are those like Mrs. Mallard who stay in an unhappy marriage.
Mrs. Mallard was already looking forward to a brighter future when she was confronted with the sad truth that her husband was not really dead. The shock was too much for her to bear and she died of a heart attack. I can only hope that women in a similar situation would find a way out of such a marriage. It is my belief that if we all truly took the time to get to know people before jumping into marriage we would have far less divorces, and even less unhappy marriages.
Pak-tung Le
EN 102
The Cathedral
In the short story, The Cathedral,
there are numerous three relationships that are discussed between a man and a
woman. The story begins with a man discussing the relationship between his wife
and her old employer, Robert. While it discusses the relationship between
Robert and the author’s wife, I will be examining the relationship between the
husband and wife. What I found
interesting that the author never reveals the names of either of the wife’s
husbands or that of the wife. To me, that represents the lack of intimacy of
the husband and wife. I also found that both of her marriages did not appear to
be satisfying to her. The author appears to be surprised that his wife appears
to be so happy when she returns with her friend. It is almost as if he has
never seen his wife smile for such an extended period of time.
As I read this
story, I found that the saying, “Familiarity breeds contempt” applied with both
of her marriages. It seems as if she is has been less content with both her
first husband, and now her current one, as time has elapsed. She appears to speak to her husband in an accusatory
fashion, be in verbal or just by looking at him. I did not find her to
understand him, however, this writing is from his perspective so that might be
the reason why it is slanted in this manner. She does not seem to be as enamored
with the author and seems to disapprove in his actions. This is illustrated
when she comes down from changing and finds the author offering Robert a joint.
Another example is when she is talking to him prior to picking up Robert. He
offers to take Robert bowling and she states that if he loved her, he would try
to be nice to her friend. She then says to him that she would do so if he had
any friends, but he does not.
question 1
This week I had to read 3 very different stories with the same meaning. What all these stories had in common was the relationship between an man and woman whether it be friendship or a romantic relationship. The common message in all these stories stories is companionship. No matter if it is romantic or not, everybody deserves and needs someone to talk to when they get lonely. My favorite story I read this week was "Dubliners" by James Joyce. This story really describes the companionship a person needs. Mr. Duffy has been on his own for his entire life. goes home to an empty space, no friends, barely any family, but the sight of one woman changed his was way of life.He now has someone to laugh with, talk to, enjoy the day with. After she was gone, she was all back to being alone. Everyone needs someone to talk to during the day, nobody wants to be alone. In the story "Catheral" by Raymond Carver, Robert, the blind man, develops a 10 year friendship with a woman. They tell each other everything including the dark times and the good days. I myself have a girlfriend and I like to think i can tell her everything, but i can't. I have one best friend. That best friend is here for me no matter what. The things I can't tell my girlfriend, I tell him. No matter what it is we as humans must get our feelings out in one form or another. Companionship is a very important part of human life, we need it to live a happy life. These stories tell us that have a friendship with a person, no matter what kind of relationship it is, makes us happy. No one wants to be alone, it is our jobs to make sure when we get older, we will never have to be alone.
Dying from a broken heart.
Stacey McDonald
February 6, 2015
English 102
Reading Response #1
Throughout all three of the short stories, the unhappy
marriages caught me by somewhat of a surprise. Particularly the one told in
“The Story of an Hour.”
In “The
Story of an Hour,” Mrs. Louise Mallard is introduced as a woman that has just
lost her husband, and since she has heart trouble, no one is quite sure how to
break this news to her. I expected what came next- sobbing, screaming, etc.
However when she suddenly took a deep breath and began to mutter “free” to
herself over and over again, I was taken aback. This was a woman who felt
neglected for most of her marriage, and was thrilled that she wouldn’t have to
suffer in silence anymore. Even though she had loved her husband, she was well
aware of the fact that he had never felt the same about her; at least not that
he had shown. Suddenly she is free from
her oppressor, and full of hope for her days ahead. When she gathers her thoughts and finally
opens the door to her sister, she probably felt reborn, to say the least. And
she definitely never expected her husband to come walking through the door.
I cannot
begin to imagine what it must be like to have to wake up every day in bed with
a man like that. However there were certain experiences in my own life
(involving my mother and stepfather,) that I found myself being able to relate
to what she went through. When you live
a life in the shadow of someone that doesn’t seem to care if you’re there or
not, the idea of a life without them can seem too good to be true. If that
dream suddenly becomes your reality, why would you ever desire to go back to
the nightmare? At the end of the story I found myself wondering what Mr.
Mallard had done to Louise over the course of their marriage to make her feel
such a way to begin with. If I had to go back to a life that left me feeling so
small, maybe I would be too overcome with sadness to continue. The doctors
may have said it was heart disease, but I think that Louise died from a broken
heart, knowing that she could not, after just an hour of imagining what her
life would be like, free of her husband, go back to living in the shadow of a
man that couldn’t seem to be bothered with her.
You see a similar situation in "A Painful Case," between Mr. Duffy and Mrs. Sinico. Mr. Duffy is man that has spent his entire life avoiding involvement of any emotional nature with another person, until he meets Mrs. Sinico at the opera one night. She is a woman trapped in a loveless marriage, with a man that thinks if he doesn't want her, there's no reason that anyone else would. They begin to see each other on a regular basis, and the second that she shows Mr. Duffy affection he pushes her away, and I think that's because since he has never had a romantic relationship, he has no idea how he is supposed to react. Time goes on and he returns to his lonely life, only to read in the newspaper four years later that Mrs. Sinico died in an apparent suicide, throwing herself in front of an oncoming train. Just then does Mr. Duffy see the ramifications of what he had done. She had been his soul mate all along. And when he pushed her away, she had to retreat into a life of loneliness, and it became too much for her to bear.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)